Soup Whoop 1 Year Report [CASE STUDY]

Y’all know I’m a travel blogger, right? Like many of you in the first half of 2020, I found myself wondering what I could to diversify my income to ensure against well, what started in the first half of 2020! To that end, I had always been kicking around the idea of starting a food blog, and I finally pulled the trigger one year ago when I launched Soup Whoop.

Soup Whoop Hero

While I certainly can’t say that the site was an out-of-the-ballpark success, I did learn a ton from my first year as a semi-food blogger. If you’re curious to see how this site went for me and what I plan to do next, this one-year case study will cover all the important info!

What are these Case Studies?

As a reminder, I’ll be doing case studies for every site I’ve created, at the 6-month, 9-month, and 12-month marks. Then I’ll switch to every six months for the next year, so you can expect reports at 18 months and 24 months. If a site reaches its two-year mark and I plan to continue writing, I’ll switch to annual reports. Here are the ages of each site and its current status:

(Links will take you to the full list of reports about that site!)

I actually didn’t do any case studies for Soup Whoop at the 6-month and 9-month milestones; as you’ll see, I sorta lost my way on this site and didn’t focus on it after the first few months. As this is the first (and maybe only?) case study report for Soup Whoop, I’ll try to give you everything I think is interesting about running this site so far, and a real “peek beneath the hood.” If you want to know anything else, be sure to let me know in the comments!

Fast Facts

Here’s a quick glance at the stats for Soup Whoop at its first anniversary:

Date First PublishedApril 1, 2021
Articles Live (as of 3/1/22)14
Publishing CadenceCurrently on hold
Monthly Pageviews (last 30 days)2836
Maximum Pageviews (in last year)7075 (February 2022)
Average Pageviews per Post203
Google Traffic83.4%
Email Subscribers0

In the rest of this post, I’ll dive more into the history of the site and what I plan to focus on next.

How do I keep track of all these stats? I’ve got an organizational system!

Get my Blogging Organization Success System and get your site organized for just $67!

Or sign up for my email list and get 25% off!

BOSS Mockup

History & Status of Great Plains Travel Guide

Soup Whoop 12mo Chart

My commitment (or lack thereof) to Soup Whoop should have been more evident to me sooner – while I originally planned to do my standard 10-10-10 launch plan, I only published three posts before the cadence fell off.

To be honest, this was the result of a few things:

  • I was managing a photographer to create the photo assets for each recipe, and we had a really hard time creating a consistent system for her producing photos in a timely fashion.
  • I found it really hard to prioritize writing soup posts – even though they are much faster to write than posts for other sites – especially as the summer went on and I added other sites to the mix that ranked faster and better, and got more traffic.

In the end, I only published posts for about five months – from early April to late August – and only 14 posts total. And funnily enough, I didn’t really start to get any traffic until October – six months in, and a month after I stopped publishing!

Content Strategy

Speaking of publishing, as this is my first post about this site, I need to cover the basics of the content strategy. I had four major categories of soups I created recipes for on Soup Whoop:

And then of course there was some overlap, where recipes might fit into more than one category.

Below you can see the breakdown of blog posts in each category (Content Breakdown) and how many pageviews each category is bringing (Pageview Breakdown):

As you can see, Copycat recipes are far and away my most traffic-driving categories (additionally, 2 of the 5 “Multi” category posts are Copycat recipes). Honestly, an entire site of copycat soup recipes would probably do a killing in the cool winter months! (Which brings me to one of my main strategic takeaways…)

Strategic Takeaways

Here are some of the many things I learned despite only working on Soup Whoop for a short time.

Takeaway #1: Soup is Seasonal

Sometimes, I feel like all the business savvy in the world doesn’t replace the obvious facts that should be common sense. Like, for example, people don’t eat hot soup during the hot summer months. You know when they eat soup? In the cold months!

So starting a soup website at the beginning of the hot summer months is a recipe – pun intended – for delayed success (if any success at all).

Takeaway #2: Food Blogging is a Whole Other World

As this was my first dedicated site for food – a food blog, if you will – I definitely had a learning curve when it came to finding any success.

For example, you probably know that there are plugins you should use for recipes specifically to get the right markup so they show properly at the top of Google. And those plugins allow people to rate and review your recipes.

But did you know there are whole groups dedicated to bloggers rating and reviewing each other’s recipes to help boost them in that part of the Google algorithm?

I didn’t know this either, until maybe November. For a time, I considered joining these “review-swapping” groups to try and get my recipes to rank better… but as I wasn’t focused on creating new content, I decided to forego this action.

Takeaway #3: The Entire Google Algorithm is Different in Food, too

As I mentioned, things work a bit differently when it comes to Google and food. If you’ve ever googled for a recipe, you’ve probably seen the recipe cards that show up at the top of the results. And then there are normal search results of recipes below, too.

Well, it turns out that ranking in the recipe cards is way easier than in the rest of the results – for almost all recipes, those will be taken by high authority/high “DA” sites. Low “DA” sites can win recipe card spots even if they will never show up on the rest of the page. But to earn those spots, it’s important to get ratings and reviews of your recipe, since that all shows up on the card and gives you more credibility to earn clicks. Who knew? (Food bloggers did, that’s who!)

Takeaway #4: Affiliates are also Different in Food

Lastly, it was a very interesting experiment to try and figure out affiliate marketing on a food blog. With travel blogs – which is most of what I do – it’s hotels, tours, gear, maybe flights… But with food?

It’s all ingredients and tools. Low-cost ingredients and relatively low-cost tools that you need to sell in bulk to make any meaningful income from. So, if you want to earn a “real” income, you need a lot of traffic to sell a lot of low-cost ingredients… if you don’t have much traffic, you’re going to earn very little for a long time until you have a lot of traffic.

These were all things I had no idea about – and barely scratched the surface of – in my thus far short foray into food blogging.

What’s Next?

What’s next for a site like this? Here are my thoughts at this point – though it’s very possible this will all change in a few months!

Site on Hold

As I mentioned, Soup Whoop has been on hold with no new content since late August 2021. This is when I lost contact with the photographer I was working with (despite sending her assignments that she agreed to do – such is the life with contractors), and not having a steady stream of photo assets coming in that needed written content.

To be honest, I haven’t figured out what to do with the site next. Sometimes I think it would be fun to keep playing around with it – other times I look at the photos that I have shot for recipes on my other sites and cringe a little bit. Visual assets are an important part of food blogging, and without good ones, I’ll probably just keep focusing on other sites.

Seasonal Content in Q3 2022?

If I do restart content, it’ll probably be in late summer 2022, since that will be well-timed to earn ranking positions in the winter months. I’ll also engage in a strategy of review-swapping to help my recipes have the best chance of showing up.

Copycat Recipes All the Way

Finally, as I do with most sites, if I decide to restart content on Soup Whoop, I’ll definitely learn from my rainmakers – aka my copycat recipes. This will necessitate doing additional keyword research and such, but seems like the best use of my time, energy, and learning curve if I do recommit to the site.

Though I’m not sure if I’ll do a two-year check-in, I’ll definitely skip the 18-month milestone for Soup Whoop – so don’t worry too much if you don’t hear anything about this site agani. Is there anything you would like to know about Soup Whoop? Let me know in the comments – I’m happy to share anything that I forgot to include!

Avatar photo

Valerie has been blogging since 2001, and has been running her oldest travel blog for a decade. You can find her across the internet on her various niche sites, but she started Site School to help fellow bloggers grow and create better content.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *